The 1st Five heeft laten weten dat O Pioneers!!! ermee gestopt zou zijn. Frontman Eric Solomon had het volgende over de breuk te zeggen:

O Pioneers!!! should have ended a long time ago. I started this band in the fall of 2004, and it's slowly changed and migrated into what it is today, based off of the millions of people that have been in this band. I got tired of trying to con people into playing songs that they liked, or may have been a fan of, but ultimately they didn't have a connection with, besides something that was at face value.